Blogs

At some point, every credit union faces the tension of more opportunity than capacity. The data surfaces gaps—markets that need more lending, member segments that aren’t being reached—but resources are finite, and you can’t pursue everything at once.

That's the problem Episode 3 of our "From Gaps to Growth" series is designed to solve. Laird and I built this session around the decisions that come after the data: how to prioritize the opportunities worth pursuing, how to set goals that are grounded in market reality, and how to match resources to what the work actually requires.

For credit unions specifically, this matters in ways that go beyond production targets. Your mission is tied to the communities you serve. The gap between that mission and your lending activity is what smart goal-setting should close.

Sizing Up the Opportunity

While opportunity is everywhere, resources are limited. That tension is where prioritization lives, and it's the first thing credit unions need to work through before setting any goal.

We encourage lenders to look through multiple lenses: What is the actual size of the opportunity—not the market, but the specific gap? How does that opportunity fit your baseline and your broader strategy? Who is competing for it, and how are they winning? And, critically, if the gap exists, do you understand why before you choose a solution?

Credit unions have a genuine advantage here, and that’s deep community trust. But lending activity doesn't always reflect it, and the gap analysis tells you exactly where the disconnect is. 

Match the Metric to the Problem

Before you can set a goal, you need to know what kind of gap you're trying to close. Here's how we think about it: 

• Application goals address demand. Choose these when not enough activity is coming from a target member group or geography.
• Origination goals address closed-loan production. Choose these when a clear production target is needed and capacity is there to support it.
• Market share goals address competitiveness. Choose these when competitors are capturing a disproportionate share.
• Penetration goals address alignment. Choose these when production does not reflect the composition of the market.
• Pull-through or conversion goals address fallout. Choose these when applications are coming in, but members are not reaching origination.
• Approval or denial-rate goals address product fit or qualification barriers. Choose these when denial rates are high or members are disproportionately unable to move forward. 
• Partnership and referral goals address trust and early member connection. Choose these when you need stronger relationships with organizations that already serve the target community.

Vague Goals Don’t Drive Action

Goals need to be anchored to something actionable—either geography (specific tracts, branches, or service areas), a member segment (LMI households, first-time buyers, majority-minority communities), or ideally both. Tying geography and segment together is where strategic clarity lives. 

Specificity is also what separates a weak goal from a strong one.

"Increase lending in underserved communities" is less of a goal and more of a sentiment. 

"Increase purchase applications from LMI members in our assessment area by 15% by next year" is better. 

"Increase purchase applications and originations in our five highest-priority LMI and majority-minority tracts by 10% to 15% over the next 12 months" is what actually drives accountability and action.

Build in the Market Context

Setting goals without accounting for market movement is a common pitfall. If the market is growing faster than your target, you're losing share. If it's contracting, you're setting your team up to fail. 

Your baseline tells you where you've been. The forecast tells you where demand is heading. Together, they produce a target that's realistic, forward-looking, and genuinely strategic. 

Consider these six questions as goal-setting steps: